Criminal Defense Attorney (AI Evaluation)

About Us

Gramian Consultancy is a boutique consultancy specializing in IT professional services and engineering talent solutions. With a strong background in software engineering and leadership, we help companies build high-performing teams by matching them with professionals who truly fit their needs.

Role Overview

We are looking for experienced US-based criminal defense attorneys to review legal scenarios, assess AI-generated legal content, and create realistic analyses based on professional criminal defense practice. The work will involve criminal procedure, evidentiary issues, plea negotiations, motions, trial strategy, and legal reasoning. No previous AI experience is required; practical legal expertise is the primary requirement.

CONTRACT: Freelance contractor, project-based

COMMITMENT: Flexible, based on project workload

LOCATIONS: Fully remote, United States

PROCESS: Application review, legal expertise assessment (AI-led), onboarding

HOURLY RATE: $140 - $400/h

NOTES: An active license to practice law and substantial criminal defense experience are required.

Responsibilities

• Review and annotate criminal law documents, court scenarios, and case materials.
• Evaluate AI-generated legal content for factual, procedural, and legal accuracy.
• Create realistic hypothetical case analyses based on criminal defense practice.
• Develop and review motions, plea agreements, legal arguments, and trial strategies.
• Analyze evidentiary issues and explain their impact on case strategy.
• Provide clear explanations of criminal procedure and legal reasoning.
• Identify legally unsound, incomplete, misleading, or ethically problematic outputs.
• Review complex fact patterns and assess potential defense approaches.
• Provide structured feedback to improve the accuracy and quality of legal AI outputs.
• Collaborate with project teams to refine evaluation standards and legal datasets.

Requirements

• Active license to practice law in a recognized jurisdiction.
• Substantial professional experience practicing criminal defense law.
• Strong knowledge of criminal law, criminal procedure, evidence, and trial advocacy.
• Hands-on experience developing case strategy and advising on criminal matters.
• Experience drafting and reviewing motions, briefs, pleadings, or plea agreements.
• Proven ability to analyze complex factual and evidentiary issues.