Supervisor, Analytics — Anti-Fraud Operations

Why Join GEICO?

At GEICO, we offer a rewarding career where your ambitions are met with endless possibilities.

Every day we honor our iconic brand by offering quality coverage to millions of customers and being there when they need us most. We thrive on relentless innovation to exceed our customers' expectations while making a real impact on local communities nationwide.

Founded in 1936, GEICO is a member of the Berkshire Hathaway family of companies and one of the largest auto insurers in the United States. When you join our company, we want you to feel valued, supported, and proud to work here. That's why we offer the GEICO Pledge: Great Company, Great Culture, Great Rewards, and Great Careers.

About the Role

GEICO is seeking an experienced Supervisor, Analytics - Anti-Fraud Operations to lead a team of analytics professionals supporting fraud investigations and fraud prevention initiatives. This role combines strong people leadership with technical expertise and requires a leader who can set priorities, develop talent, oversee high-quality analytics delivery, and partner effectively with investigative, compliance, claims, and technology stakeholders.

This position is ideal for a leader who can coach and mentor analysts, influence decision-making at multiple levels, and ensure analytical solutions are accurate, timely, and actionable within a fast-paced, highly regulated environment.

Key Responsibilities

Team Leadership & Development

• Lead, coach, and develop a team of analytics associates.
• Manage performance, workload distribution, and career development.
• Foster a collaborative, accountable, and high-performing team culture.
• Provide guidance and support to help associates strengthen technical and communication skills.

Analytics Delivery & Execution

• Oversee the end-to-end delivery of analytics work, from intake and prioritization through quality review and completion.
• Ensure analytical deliverables meet standards for accuracy, reliability, and business impact.
• Guide development of: Reporting and dashboards Enterprise data analysis Ad hoc analytical support for investigations
• Review analytical approaches, challenge assumptions, and help resolve complex problems.

Business Partnership & Stakeholder Management

• Partner with SIU and fraud leadership to align analytics initiatives with investigative priorities and business objectives.
• Collaborate with Claims, Compliance, Operations, and Technology teams on: System releases Training initiatives Issue resolution Continuous improvement efforts
• Communicate effectively with leaders and stakeholders across the organization.

Governance, Risk & Quality

• Establish and maintain standards for: Documentation Testing and validation Quality assurance Responsible use of data
• Identify operational, data, and security risks and drive appropriate mitigation strategies.
• Ensure compliance with company policies and regulatory requirements.

Required Qualifications

Education & Experience

• Bachelor's degree or an equivalent combination of education and professional experience.
• Prior supervisory or people leadership experience required.
• Ability to learn and apply complex technical and procedural information.
• Ability to work in a fast-paced environment while managing multiple priorities.

Leadership Skills

• Proven success leading analytical or technical teams.
• Strong coaching and mentoring capabilities.
• Excellent written and verbal communication skills.
• Ability to build alignment among diverse stakeholders and constructively resolve conflicts.
• Strong organizational and decision-making abilities.

Technical & Industry Knowledge

• Knowledge of insurance fraud investigations, Special Investigations Unit (SIU) operations, compliance analytics, or a related field.
• Experience working with one or more of the following tools and technologies: SQL Cloud data platforms (Snowflake or similar) Power BI or other business intelligence/reporting tools Python or similar programming languages Data pipelines and ETL processes Git or other version-control systems
• Ability to review technical work and provide strategic direction without excessive oversight.
• Experience supporting production analytics environments is preferred.

Professional Skills

• Ability to handle sensitive information with discretion.
• Strong partnership skills with operations leaders, investigators, and analytics or engineering teams.
• Effective telephone and written communication skills.

Preferred Qualifications

• Leadership experience in: Special Investigations Unit (SIU) Fraud analytics Insurance claims investigations
• Experience leading teams responsible for both recurring reporting and ad hoc analytics.
• Familiarity with structured intake, prioritization, and project tracking processes within a cross-functional organization.
• Experience supporting production analytics environments, including: Defect resolution Stakeholder sign-off processes Solution deployment and rollout

Preferred Locations

• Getzville, NY
• Buffalo, NY
• Fredericksburg, VA

Remote work may be considered for highly qualified candidates.

Why GEICO?

Join a team where analytics plays a critical role in protecting customers and the business through fraud detection and prevention. In this role, you will lead a talented team of analysts, help shape investigative strategies through data-driven insights, and expand your leadership impact while supporting a mission-driven area of the organization.

Equal Employment Opportunity

GEICO is an equal opportunity employer. Reasonable accommodations may be made for qualified individuals with disabilities to enable them to perform the essential functions of this position.

#LI-GC1

Annual Salary

The above annual salary range is a general guideline. Multiple factors are taken into consideration to arrive at the final hourly rate/ annual salary to be offered to the selected candidate. Factors include, but are not limited to, the scope and responsibilities of the role, the selected candidate’s work experience, education and training, the work location as well as market and business considerations.

The GEICO Pledge:

Great Company: Protecting customers through life’s twists and turns with innovation and integrity.

Great Careers: Personalized development programs, mentorship, and certification assistance.

Great Culture: Inclusive and collaborative culture rooted in shared success.

Great Rewards: Competitive pay, benefits, and flexibility to support your well-being and future.

The equal employment opportunity policy of the GEICO Companies provides for a fair and equal employment opportunity for all associates and job applicants regardless of race, color, religious creed, national origin, ancestry, age, gender, pregnancy, sexual orientation, gender identity, marital status, familial status, disability or genetic information, in compliance with applicable federal, state and local law. GEICO hires and promotes individuals solely on the basis of their qualifications for the job to be filled.

GEICO reasonably accommodates qualified individuals with disabilities to enable them to receive equal employment opportunity and/or perform the essential functions of the job, unless the accommodation would impose an undue hardship to the Company. This applies to all applicants and associates. GEICO also provides a work environment in which each associate is able to be productive and work to the best of their ability. We do not condone or tolerate an atmosphere of intimidation or harassment. We expect and require the cooperation of all associates in maintaining an atmosphere free from discrimination and harassment with mutual respect by and for all associates and applicants.